One of the kings of impressions, Dana Carvey, visited another pretty strong impressionist in Jimmy Fallon on The Tonight Show. Naturally, the two former SNLers played a friendly game of Wheel of Impressions, where you’re given a person and a topic to talk on.

The two kept with the spirit of the Halloween holiday and impersonated the likes of Mick Jagger discussing corn mazes, Keith Richards giving out candy and Paul McCartney dishing on his favorite horror films. The impressions were strategically chosen, as Fallon has impersonated the Rolling Stones frontman several times and the same can be said about Carvey and McCartney.

Replay the segment below.